Good Questions


On Facebook this morning a friend had posted a photo of a cruelly confined pig at a factory farm desperatly chewing on the bars of her cage. A caption read, “If your God had wanted us to eat animals, do you really think he would have given them the ability to feel pain and fear? What kind of sadistic individual would that make him?!”

Good questions. Taking it a step further, I have to wonder…if god had wanted us to eat animals, do you really think he would have given us the ability to feel their pain and fear?!

Unfortunately, empathy and compassion are not doled out equally to all.

Some people feel them so strongly it literally pains us to hear about the brutalities inflicted on nonhumans by their fellow man. The sadness is outweighed only by the understanding that many of the animal cruelties are so widespread and so accepted by society it will require nothing short of a major revolution in thinking to put an end to them. For those of us so well-endowed with empathy and compassion, every KFC, Arby’s or McDonalds commercial, every shiny photo ad for this weeks’ meat and dairy specials at the local market, every camo-clad nimrod in a pickup truck sporting an NRA bumper sticker inspires feelings of grief, anguish or anger.

There are those, Temple Grandin, for instance, may be able to feel empathy but apparently not compassion. Her autism allegedly allows her to experience the fear and anxiety factory farmed animals go through, yet her lack of compassion allows her to work for the animal industries, helping to spread the absurd, feel-good myth that some animals are “humanely” raised (and slaughtered), thereby giving consumers a license to ignore any twinges of empathy or compassion they might have.

And there are many who are completely incapable of feeling empathy for others. They’re the lucky ones—if hollowness, selfishness and superficiality are to be considered enviable traits.

13 thoughts on “Good Questions

  1. It disgusts me to see people happily defending their meat consumption using Temple Grandin as a license to gorge on slaughter, calling it humane, while if this humane “rearing and processing” were done to them or a loved one people’s screams of horror would echo around the world.

  2. My favorite is “If god didn’t want us to eat animals then why are they made out of meat” my response: “well humans (which are animals too) are also “made out of meat” so gladly go around munching on people.” gets em’ every time.

  3. Another excellent post raising perceptive questions about the irreconcilability of purported belief in an all-powerful, all-merciful god and systematized animal abuse (I can’t be the only one who’s noticed the strong correlation between Christian religiosity and serial animal abuse in this country, am I?) and an insightful distinction between empathy alone versus empathy + compasion.

  4. Temple Grandin confuses me – with due respect to whatever good she may have done, it bothers me that her “condition” somehow makes her opinions and theories immune to discussion. I don’t believe how you build the shoot that feeds the animals into the slaughter house or much of the rest of it makes much difference. An animal (let’s hope humans know as much) knows it is being herded into a place of death. When you get wedged in a vice and a big thump hits your head, you better hope it is all over – or you may end up dangling by one leg dying in a worse way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s