Florida Black Bear Hunt Represents Failure of Wildlife Management

By On October 26, 2015 · 43 Comments · In Wildlife News

Florida just held its first bear hunt in several decades, targeting 300 of the bruins for death. Just three years ago, the black bear was listed as threatened, and the state’s bears had not been hunted since 1994.

The proximate reason for the hunt is that bears, according to representatives of the Florida Wildlife Commission, is that a growing bear population is contributing to greater conflicts between humans and bears. Hunters and the Wildlife Commission like to portray the issue as “problem bears”, but the reality is that there are no problem bears, only problem humans.

Most of these conflicts are due to human negligence. People leaving food attractants like unsecured garbage cans which train bears to forage near humans.

Ironically, indiscriminate hunting is not likely to reduce conflicts. For one thing, most hunters do not hunt immediately next to subdivisions where most conflicts are occurring. Rather they are most likely to the larger parcels of public or private lands. So the animals that hunters are killing, are not likely to be the ones that are wandering the edges of communities.

The second problem with indiscriminate hunting is that it’s difficult for a hunter to determine the sex of a bear. Many females with cubs are killed, leaving the young bears orphaned. Orphaned bears are inexperienced at foraging and desperate to eat, are more likely to be attracted to human foods.

So in effect, hunting only exacerbates the problem that the Florida Wildlife Commission seeks to solve.

The worse part of the hunt is that it ignores the social ecology of predators. Fish and Game agency always talk about maintaining populations. The problem with this kind of management is that it ignores the demographics of wildlife. Hunting tends to skew populations towards younger animals. So even if you maintain the same “population” if the population consists of many young inexperienced animals, you automatically create conflicts. Young animals are less likely to know the location of natural food resources, and are less successful as hunters. As a consequence, they are the very animals most likely to seek out garbage, livestock, and other human food resources.

Whether it is hunting of black bears in Florida, or the recent announcement by Oregon’s Fish and Wildlife to increase cougar hunting, wildlife agencies across the country tend to ignore predator social ecology. In effect, by having indiscriminate hunting and trapping of predators, these state wildlife agencies create a self-reinforcing loop. Predators are killed, resulting in a younger population, which in turn is more likely to create human conflicts, that are then used as an additional justification for more killing.

I see no evidence anywhere that state wildlife agencies are using the latest ecological science in their attitude and management of predators. It suggests that wildlife agencies cannot be trusted to manage predators. Keep in mind, that predators numbers will not grow indefinitely. They are self-managing, primarily by the availability of prey and food, as well as social interaction. Except perhaps for very specific surgical removal of individual animals, there is no good justification for killing predators. Even the argument that “I’m feeding my family” used by some hunters seldom applies to most predators which are not usually consumed.

Predators serve an important ecological function. Bears, for instance, move seeds of some plants around—think of the huckleberry that may be deposited in their droppings. Cougar can thin elk and deer herds to reduce their herbivory on favor plants like aspen and willow. Wolves can remove the injured and sick from a population.

Hunting of predators makes no sense in today’s world.



5 thoughts on “Florida Black Bear Hunt Represents Failure of Wildlife Management

  1. “The majority of FWC commissioners have no background in animal welfare, biology, zoology or environmental protection. They are instead a group primarily made up of hunters and developers appointed by notoriously environmentally unfriendly Gov. Rick Scott,” said Paul Waller, of Coconut Creek.”

    Is it any wonder this disgusting event turned so quickly into such a free-for-all? I love the pretending not to know why the protesters are there too.


    And here’s a funny one:


  2. Actually, this is what wildlife “management” agencies do. They “manage” for the benefit of hunters and trappers, certainly not for the benefit of the species or the general public. I see that as the core of the problem. Most people don’t understand the purpose of these agencies and don’t challenge the assumption that “surplus” animals should always be available to persecute, torture, and kill for the delight of the recreational killing public. That is what “recovered populations” are all about: now we have enough animals to go out & really have some fun.

    I was reading something the other day about wolves and was really annoyed, so I called Bruce Dale, Director of “Wildlife Conservation” at Alaska Fish & Game. I pushed him on the idea of ethics, and his response was that ethics applies to the integrity of the data he provides to the Commission (i.e., animal counts & how many “surplus”) — & nothing related to values. Once again, I see this as a huge problem. They call this “science” because it is emotionless and recognizes nothing other than numbers. Concepts of suffering, family disruption, compassion, the greater good are ignored & ridiculed. This is my definition of hell.

  3. Pingback: Florida Black Bear Hunt Represents Failure of Wildlife Management | butterbloomcom

  4. This is all right on! & I love the one where the hunters use ” I’m feeding my family” as if there’s not enough food sources so awful.!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s