How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal Issues

How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal IssuesPin

I have never been a single-issue voter.  I like to think I am intelligent enough to look at the big picture and make my voting decision based on how a candidate stands on multiple issues. But I have to admit that animal welfare issues can weigh heavily on my choice of candidate.

We have come so far in the past few years: animal abuse is finally a felony in all fifty states, it is now a crime to even attend a dog or cock fighting event, many communities are passing laws to outlaw puppy mill dogs in pet stores, and even the White House has come out against breed discrimination.  But we are far from where we need to be as a humane nation.

Related: 7 Reasons Why A Dog Should Be President: The Case For America’s First DOTUS


7 Reasons Why A Dog Should Be President: The Case For America’s First DOTUS

To help me make my voting decision in the upcoming presidential election, I went online to research the front-runner candidates.  For some, those who have served in the US Senate or House, it was as easy as checking the ratings on the Humane Society Legislative Fund. Others required a little more digging.

I started by visiting each candidate’s website and reading through their issues page.  Unfortunately, only one candidate mentioned animal issues:  Bernie Sanders.  Senator Sanders dedicated an entire page to his stance on animal welfare.

For the rest of the field, I had to drill down deeper.  I did newspaper searches to see how candidates had voted or what bills they had signed, which affected animals.  I read opinion pieces.  I looked at state websites and tracked local bills.

Here, in a nutshell, is the information I was able to find on each of the top Presidential Candidates:

Donald Trump and Beagle


Donald Trump (GOP): Trump has never held public office.  There is no record of him every doing anything in favor of or against animals.  Although both of his sons are trophy hunters, he is on record as saying he doesn’t understand their activities and doesn’t support hunting.  However, he tweeted some disparaging comments on the Ringling Brothers Circus decision to retire their elephants early: “Ringling Brothers is phasing out their elephants.  I, for one, will never go again.  They probably used the animal rights stuff to reduce costs.”

Marco Rubio Family And Dog


Marco Rubio (GOP): Senator Rubio has a dismal average Humane Society Legislative Fund (HSLF) rating of 12 (out of 100) for his voting record in the US Senate, although he did co-sponsor a bill to make “soring” a crime. Soring is a painful technique to make a gaited horse lift his feet as high as possible.  It is a cruel and painful process.  Senator Rubio’s campaign website does not address animals at all.

Ted Cruz and Family

Source: Ted Cruz


Ted Cruz (GOP): Senator Cruz’ HSLF rating is even lower. His average for the three years he has served in the Senate is a 4 (out of 100).  The only piece of legislation that he supported that was in an animal’s best interest was a vote against allowing hunting in the National Parks. His campaign website does not address animals at all.

John Kasich and Dog

Source: Dispatch


John Kasich (GOP): Governor Kaisch has a mixed record as far as animal welfare issues go.  He signed into law a tough anti-puppy mill bill and a bill protecting pets in the event of domestic violence, but he did nothing to address factory farming, and some Ohio residents feel that he dragged his feet before signing the bill outlawing exotic animals (big cats).  Although he does not address animal welfare issues on his campaign website, overall Governor Kasich has the best record of any GOP candidate.

Hillary Clinton and Animals


Hillary Clinton (DEM): When Secretary Clinton was a US Senator, she had an excellent rating with the HSLF, even getting 100+ one year. Her average for her 4 years in the Senate is a 92.  She voted for a positive outcome for animals almost every time. Since she left the Senate, she has little opportunity to influence animal legislation.  Her campaign website does not address animal issues at all.

Dogs For Bernie Sanders


Bernie Sanders (DEM): Senator Sanders has the most extensive record of any of the candidates.  I was able to obtain his HSLF rating for 11 years. His average rating is 97 out of 100, and there were multiple years he scored 100 and twice when he scored 100+ ,,, only time I can find a vote that can be deemed not to be in an animal’s best interest, is a vote Senator Sanders made to support hunting in the National Parks.\

How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal Issues


10 thoughts on “How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal Issues

  1. In almost all cases, my values align most closely with Bernie’s. However, learning that he voted in support of hunting in national parks is confusing and disturbing. What the hell?

  2. Sanders vote on the national parks hunting issue (bi partisan heritage act support) greatly concerned me as it also aligns with his stance on guns. I can’t support anyone that would vote for the bipartisan heritage act despite the other issues I agree with

    From: Exposing the Big Game Reply-To: Exposing the Big Game Date: Friday, April 22, 2016 at 1:46 PM To: louise kane Subject: [New post] 11847 Exposing the Big Game posted: “How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal Issues Pin Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Pinterest JC Johnson Writer 2 months ago 41.4K Shares Share Tweet Pin shares Share on Face”

  3. If anything, the guns need to get OUT of the National Parks, and hunting in the National Parks is an outrage. I cannot support Bernie if he supports guns in the parks. These days, I’m pretty much becoming a single-issue voter, or a few issues voter, for those that are important and always neglected and abused. This country is gun crazy and an embarrassment to the world. Is there no place here where guns are not allowed?

  4. I’m a republican and a single-issue voter. Before reading this post, my values most aligned with Bernie – aside from him being a democrat – knowing that he is a great voice and supporter for animal protection but after reading this post I can’t fathom why he would in favor of hunting?! It just doesn’t sound like him based on his other views. Now I have to reevaluate my stance..

  5. Pingback: How The Presidential Candidates Stack Up When It Comes To Animal Issues – Making Waves Outreach

  6. How a Congressman voted on the “Bipartisan Sportsman’s Act” (now re-christened “SHARE”) should be the litmus test of their sincerity regarding wildlife and wild lands preservation. This is the single most destructive piece of wildlife legislation in living memory. Anybody who supports it should be beyond the pale of support for any animal advocate. True wild animal enthusiasts like Senators Barbara Boxer and Corey Booker have gone on record opposing this abominable piece of legislation. Sanders, despite all the crocodile tears for the disadvantaged, abused and underdogs of our society, supported it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s